Teaching Kids To Share Is Tricky. Here’s How I Did It

Portrait of schoolgirl passing red apple to classmate during lesson

We’ve all seen the exchanges between toddlers and their caregivers:

“It’s time to give your truck to Charlie now.”
“MINE!”
“No, you have to share.”
“NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!”

As a mother, I’m very familiar with the feeling of dread that comes over me when my son refuses to share or snatches a toy from another child’s hands. There’s an immediate urge to apologize for his behavior or point out how he’s such a good sharer normally. Often I have to resist the urge to jump in and play referee.

It seems like a collective parental mission to perfect our children’s ability to share from a very young age, as though their future as a conscientious, functioning member of society depends on it. It’s a noble goal — but I also think it’s worth examining if we’re going about it in the most suitable way.

First, we should probably take a step back and acknowledge that sharing in itself is kind of a weird thing. I mean, if I was in a park playing with my ball and someone walked over and took it away from me, I’d think that was odd. And to then be told by someone else that I had to give it up because it’s “time to share” probably wouldn’t improve the situation.

And yet this is often exactly the kind of “sharing” that our children experience. It’s no wonder they sometimes push back against the idea!

Second, it’s really important to keep in mind the developmental state of the people we’re talking to. These little beings are exploring their newfound realization of individuality, with the possibility of possession that comes with it. And their underdeveloped sense of time outside the present moment means that they want what they want Right. Now.

On top of all of this, they’re still in the early stages of learning impulse control (something that many of us still struggle with as adults).

Finally, consider that the idea of sharing is very conceptual. It doesn’t mean much to a toddler outside of the meaning he derives from you when he does, or doesn’t, execute it well. In other words: praise him for sharing, and your child will share for the sake of your praise. Scold her for not sharing and she’ll share simply to avoid your disapproval.

Sharing for the sake of sharing is lost in those scenarios. It’s a shame, because sharing provides a perfect opportunity to expose our children to ideals of empathy and altruism. And isn’t that what we’re really after with the extreme focus on sharing in the first place?

So, the question remains, given all of this, how do we as parents approach sharing in a more suitable way? Here are three little tricks I’ve learned that have done wonders for my son’s willingness to share:

1. Don’t deny ownership — reinforce it.

When my son grabs a toy and proclaims “MINE,” I don’t shush him. If the toy is actually his, I affirm his statement (“yes, sweetheart, that is your truck”).

If the ownership claim was made because someone else was encroaching on the toy, I’ll add, “Do you think your friend would like to play with it, too?” This provides security so he knows that giving a turn doesn’t mean giving up the toy for good.

If the toy in question doesn’t belong to him, I gently correct him: “No, my love. That truck belongs to your friend. Isn’t it nice that he’s letting you play with it?” This reminds him to actually experience how good it feels to be on the receiving end and also prepares him for leaving the toy behind.

2. Drop the word “share,” and don’t play referee.

When a dispute over a toy breaks out, instead of imploring kids to share, I suggest taking turns. Since this can be a little conceptual too, I remind them what that means in simple turns. “First, [child with current possession] will have a turn. After she’s done, it will be [other child’s] turn.”

I’ve found timing the turns to be counterproductive, causing kids to hold on to something in anticipation, or meltdown at the arbitrary “end of the turn” moment. Kids will usually pass the toy on in their own time, or lose interest and walk away.

It rarely comes to this, but if a toy is causing strife and turn-taking isn’t resolving it, I’m not beyond suggesting that we put it away for a rest. Taking turns usually looks like a happy alternative immediately.

3. Approach breakdowns as learning opportunities.

No matter how intentional you are about giving your child tools to weather sharing, there will be meltdown moments. Instead of feeling frustrated or embarrassed when they do occur, try to create a safe space for your child to express and process what they’re feeling.

Some questions I frequently ask in these moments are:

  • What’s happening right now, my love?
  • What are you feeling?
  • How do you think your friend might be feeling right now?
  • What do you think it was like for our friend when you grabbed that away from her?
  • Can you think of any solution that would make everyone happy?

These questions help kids have a sense of being heard and teach them to watch and regulate their emotions. It also helps them experience empathy by imagining how someone else is feeling. Plus, it helps you to get on their page and establish yourself as a trusted ally. And by inviting their ideas about solutions, you’re showing them that you value their opinions.

As with most things in parenting, I’ve found that how all of this goes depends less on my son’s willingness to do what I’m asking of him and more on my own attachment to my expectations of exactly how he should be behaving in any given moment. Softening those attachments has consistently produced a more enjoyable parenting experience.

 

2016-02-19T10:26:58+00:00

Related Questions

  • Click here to view in a new window

    Q: I have been listening to the Warren Balentine show and I heard you share your knowledge and wisdom all the time. I was just informed by my PCP that I had an abnormal pap and tested positive for HPV. I go have to go and see my OB tomorrow so they can scrape my cervix. I was diagnosed with this disease back in 1996 before I got married. Since then, I have given birth to four children. My last pap was before my fourth child and it was a normal pap. What products do you offer that can help fight and get rid of this disease. I do not want to take anything they might prescribe. I do not trust the drug industry at all. Your help would be appreciated.

    A:

    I would suggest you first perform the FULL BODY DETOX kit first, then the ANTI-VIRAL CLEANSE AND REGIMEN, followed by the TOTAL WOMAN CLEANSE. Drink FEMALE HEALTH TEA daily even while doing these cleanses. You can heal from HPV. It happens all the time!

  • Click here to view in a new window

    Q: I like to request authoriziation to submit and share My Writings Monthly to Dherb for all to be inspired and empowered as a Freelance writer giving back. After reading the article on chemotherapy I am willing to share my Gift for so often healing starts in the mind.

    A:

    Sure! Submit to me at this e-mail address; Or, you can post them directly on our â€COMMUNITY BOARD†under "Spiritual/Inspirational."

  • Click here to view in a new window

    Q: First I want to say thank, Yah has blessed you with knowledge and you share it with others. Ignorance is sin. I was reading your page about cancer and wanted to know should I stop using Vaseline also, I stop using lotions because of the ingredients and started using vaseline. Please share your wisdom.

    A:

    Yes! You would be wise to stop using Vaseline which is nothing but congealed petroleum (mineral oil). This crap has no business on the human body. It's toxic! It prevents the pores of the skin from breathing. Discard it! Instead, use Un-Petroleum, a safe alternative.

  • Click here to view in a new window

    Q: I just had a child 5 months ago... every now and then this really sad or hopeless feeling comes over me and I just want to cry for no reason. Even before I got pregnant I would get these feelings, I don't understand why because I'm pretty happy for the most part. Do you know what I can do to help me with this? Also, I have a swollen Lymphoid on my neck. It has been there for about 4 or 5yrs now. Do you have anything that would take the swelling out? I checked with a massage therapist and they wanted a statement from the doctor first but the last time I went to the doctor she said something about a biopsy so I didn't go back.

    A:

    SOUNDS LIKE POST-NATAL DEPRESSION DUE TO MINERAL DEFICIENCY. FOR THE SITUATION AND THE LYMPH NOID PROBLEM I WOULD RECOMMEND PERFORMING THE FULL BODY DETOX AND CHANGING YOUR DIET, EATING RAW AND VEGAN FOODS. FRUITS COME FROM A WORD THAT MEANS, "JOY" AND VEGETABLES FROM A WORD THAT MEANS "GROWTH" SO FOR MORE JOY AND GROWTH IN YOUR LIFE, EAT MORE FRUITS AND VEGETABLES. OUR ELATION INSPIRANT MAY ALSO BE OF GREAT USE FOR YOU.

  • Click here to view in a new window

    Q: If I gave the SUGAR BUSTER to my child for adhd what effect is it going to have on them compared to what they are taking now, one is on addrell and the other is concerta? I have no idea! I really don't believe in ADD! ADD only means a child is too advanced and is greatly bored in the classroom learning non-mentally stimulating things for an old world paradigm. However, the drugs you are giving those innocent children are harming their bodies and overall health. Problems are not fixed by drugging. Have you read our article entitled "ATTENTION-DEFICIT DISORDER"?

    A:

    I have no idea! I really don't believe in ADD! ADD only means a child is too advanced and is greatly bored in the classroom learning non-mentally stimulating things for an old world paradigm. However, the drugs you are giving those innocent children are harming their bodies and overall health. Problems are not fixed by drugging. Have you read our article entitled "ATTENTION-DEFICIT DISORDER"?

  • Click here to view in a new window

    Q: At this time I would like to share, and ask for prayer until I am in a better financial situation to purchase items from your site. On February 25th, a day after my birthday, I am having an outpatient procedure done to excise areas affected by the HPV virus down below. I am terrified and don't want to go through with it, but at this time I feel I have to. I am so anxious and excited about gettings things together to be able to purchase the Full Body Cleanse, and anything else that I will need. I have struggled for years with issues concerning my female organs, pain with PMS, never been pregnant (don't think I can), and ovarian cysts. I just want my life back, I want energy and I want to feel and be healthy! I visit the site almost every single day, and I find it so interesting. It just makes me say," I can't wait to do this!" Since, I don't know where to start, I will schedule a visit so I know exactly what I need after the Full Body Cleanse.

    A:

    Please take time to read the following article Human Papilloma Virus (HPV). Until you can afford the cleanse your body start eating plenty of raw vegetables, and fresh fruit daily.

     

     

  • Click here to view in a new window

    Q: I had a question regarding the chicken pox and other child sickness. I wanted to know what must I give my 8 month old baby if he do get the chicken pox or other sickness. I haven?t given him any vaccination, so he is clean of all that pollution that they are given the children. Could you please advice what I must do if he gets that. And also he are teething and he has some slime on his chest, I?m giving him some sweet basil and also mint tea to see if he can pass it out. If you have any other bush that I can give him please let me know.

    A: Give your child plenty of immune boosting herbs -- Pau D'Arco, Astragulus, Echinacea, Goldenseal and Cat's Claw. Make a tea of them and sweeten them with maple syrup or agave nectar.

    We have an article on "the dangers of childhood vaccines" on our site under "articles" you may find interesting!

  • Click here to view in a new window

    Q: I have a child and she will be nine this year. I have not been able to get pregnant since then, both partners I tried with; have gotten other females pregnant so why is it taking me such a long time to conceive another child. I’ve been on birth controls before and just stop because they where making my body feel weird so what would you suggest that I do about the situation.

    A:

    TIME TO REBOOT YOUR FEMALE REPRODUCTIVE SYSTEM. FIRST, DETOXIFY YOUR BODY (FULL BODY DETOX) NEXT, PERFORM THE TOTAL WOMAN CLEANSE. LASTLY, PERFORM THE FERTILITY CLEANSE. YOUR THOUGHTS SHOULD BE DOMINATED BY THOUGHTS OF PREGNANCY. VISUALIZE YOURSELF PREGNANT. AFFIRM YOUR FERTILITY THROUGHOUT THE DAY. USE YOUR MIND TO ACHIEVE YOUR DESIRES!

  • Click here to view in a new window

    Q: My 2-year-old child’s iron was 11, and I was told that it was low in 2007. Just checked it last week it's 9.2 please let me know how I can take it up and keep it up? As a parent it's important that my kids are in good health, and I'm open to any good health suggestions you may have.

    A:

    I suggest Dherbs.Com IRON EXTRACT and KHEMETIAN GOLD. Give to the child everyday!

  • Click here to view in a new window

    Q: I have had recurrent ankle trauma (refrigerated grate fell on it, then a computer and then ankle twist). I have problems with the Achilles not feeling normal and the area outside my knee on the same leg feeling abnormal. I had an MRI two weeks ago and they think it is in my mind. However my ankle and leg says otherwise. It is better however I am athletic and want to resume tennis and golf soon. Your comments welcomed! Thanks the previous email was for a friend I will share. Over the past six months I recommended the FULL BODY DETOX to several people. I feel as though I am the East & South coast as well as Europe "Marketing Director for Dherbs.com". I tell everyone that will listen and even those in denial. So how can I get benefits from my referrals and STOCK? I am leaving for Egypt with hopes my journey will shower all those associated with me with favor

    A:

    ARE YOU CAPRICORN, AQUARIUS, OR PISCES? THESE SIGNS USUALLY HAVE AILMENTS SUCHAS WHAT YOU DESCRIBE. CAPRICORN GOVERNS THE LEGS (AND KNEES), AQUARIUS GOVERNS THE ANKLES AND PISCES THE FEET. YOU ARE ATTRACTING THESE INJURIES VIA THOUGHT. A MESSAGE IS BEING CONVEYED, PERHAPS ABOUT THE DIRECTION OF YOUR LIFE. IT WOULD TAKE A FULL CONSULTATION TO GET TO THE ROOT OF THE PROBLEM. GIVE THE BODY PARTS NUTRITION IN THE FORM OF MSM SULFUR, JOINTS FORMULA AND HEADACHE AND PAIN FORMULA. WE GIVE 15% DISCOUNTS FOR WRITTEN TESTIMONIES. WE REALLY HAVE NO WAY TO TRACK REFERRALS, SO WE RELY UPON TESTIMONIALS TO REWARD PEOPLE FOR ALL THEY DO FOR DHERBS.COM. QUESTION, HOW DID YOU DISCOVER DHERBS.COM?

  • Click here to view in a new window

    Q: Is it possible for a mother, and daughter to still share an aura after the age of two? If so, why? What would be the purpose of such a thing?

    A:

    By age 2 a child usually develops their own aura unless mother, and child have a unique tight bond. A child is influenced a lot by its mother's energy (aura), so it is not uncommon for a mother's aura to be the same as her child's past the age of 2. It could also be that both simply operate from the same emotions. The mother may have the spirit of child due to being spiritual.

  • Click here to view in a new window

    Q: Unfortunately my child did get vaccinated due mostly in part to my ignorance to the law. I must admit the administration wore me down with the threats and medical exam fee that kept stating that their immunization was low. I don't believe the hype!!! I did give them charcoal and Bentonite clay right after the shots. I also took them both off of the meats and dairy completely (as we were transitioning into a raw food diet). They are looking at me long faced now but I believe that they will appreciate it later. :-) What I can take from this experience as a learning lesson and help others that maybe in a similar situation and simply do not know what to do. All the information that you have on your website is amazing (I am a Dherbs junkie). You said it best that knowledge is power and I truly understand that statement now. Thank you for all that you do and just know that your works are appreciated.

    A:

    Did you read our article on â€THE DANGERS OF VACCINATIONS†I have created a NEW vaccine waiver kit that folks will be able to order from Dherbs and give to all administrations. It includes an affidavit of objection, an affidavit to the nurse assuming 100% full responsibility for the inoculation, and a request for chemical ingredient of the vaccine. Have the child perform CHILDREN DETOX (liquid extracts) too (within the next 30 days). Stay strong and move forward more knowledgeable than you were.

  • Click here to view in a new window

    Q: I think it is interesting that you spend a lot of time pushing your personal opinions and share limited advice. What do you understand about integrity and professionalism? Or even respect for others? I do not see it. If people are looking to you for help why do you spit on their problems? I was researching your site to help a client resolve their addiction to smoking. I have to say I was sadly disappointed to read your article. It is not helpful nor is it informative. In fact it enforces shame and negativity on those who seek help and positive life changes. I would hope you could restructure your article to benefit all. It would be beneficial to check out higher consciousness sites on herbal healing. I wish for you in this moment to find peace and resolve your anger and prejudice that is so apparent in your articles. Love, light and peace.

    A:

    YOUR perception is not MY reality, Love. I am doing me and you do you. Tell you what: you do what I am failing to do or what you feel I am failing to do. This would be more appropriate. Pick up the ball where you deem it dropped. Talk is cheap and actions speak. I have done the actions and am doing them (read the reviews and testimonies on Dherbs.com). It speaks for itself. My new smoking article will reflect where I am presently, but it will still blast the ignorant cigarette smokers. One can't just blame government and the cigarette industry for the actions of the dumb cigarette smoker. Dumb and weak Americans must also foot partial blame, actually most of it, because they had a choice and there was no gun to their head forcing them to smoke. These people were simply weak and stupid and not to mention unconscious. Period! It doesn't sound nice but it's factual and truthful. I don't sugar coat the truth because sugar is a poison! The first article was written 6-7 years ago and that's why it's so brief. Thank you for visiting the #1 website in all-natural herbal products and raw uncompromising information that people all across the world are eating up and just can't get enough of.

  • Click here to view in a new window

    Q: I was wondering if you had any insights as to why I experience "warm flashes" during the luteal phase of my menstrual cycle. I've been sampling your Female Hormonal Formulas, for some time now, and while some products have helped lengthen my cycle, I still am having the hot feeling. I'm 36 years old, have never had a child, and am wondering if there's any way I can "preserve" my fertility up until age 40.

    A:

    It's never hopeless unless you agree to believe that it is. Have you performed a female based cleanse (Total Woman Cleanse)? Any warming (i.e. hot flashes) pertains to dumping off toxins, but usually due to the uterus being taxed. How's your uterine health? Any problems in that area?

    Product Links:
    Total Woman Cleanse

  • Click here to view in a new window

    Q: My wife and I would like to experience the full body cleanse together. Since the kit costs $120.00 ea., is it possible for us to share one kit together and then purchase a second kit within a 2 week period from the time that we purchased the first kit?

    A:

    Yes, you may purchase one Full Body Cleanse and purchase another within ten days to stay on track!

  • Click here to view in a new window

    Q: I recently found out the man I have been involved with, fathered another child with someone else. It really hurts, and I dont know if I can get over it. He wants me to stay, but not sure I can its so painful. I dont really talk to anyone about it. I just need understanding, and I want to stop feeling angry. I want to contiue to live my life.

    A:

    Maybe you need to take a time out from your relationship. Do some soul searching. Sometimes being away from the person you are upset with, gives you the clarity to make the right decision for yourself. There is a lot more to this than is presented here, so take the time to think through what you REALLY want. If you love him and want to forgive him that is fine. If you don't that is fine too. Either way your life is going to go on. This is a crossroads, and only you have the answer of whats best for you. Go within for the answers.
    You can purchase our Science of You DVD to help you get through this process faster and create the life you desire.

  • Click here to view in a new window

    Q: GREETING, I FOUND YOUR PRODUCT WHEN A FRIEND OF MINE WAS USING IT FOR A SKIN AN OTHER DISORDERS.....AND I NOTICING A BIG DIFFERENCE AN HE NOTICE THE SAME.....MY QUESTION IS ON THE MALE FORMULA, I'M CURRENTLY ON BLOOD PRESSURE MEDS AN ORAL DIABETES MEDS.....WOULD TAKING THE FORMULA HAVE ANY AFFECTS WITH THOSE MEDS I MENTION.....IF NOT HOW OFFTEN DO I STAY WITH IT, OR JUST A ONE TIME USE AN A MAINTENCE SCHEDULE AFTER THAT.....I'M CURRENTLY DOING A DETOX NOW WITH ANOTHER PRODUCT SORRY.....I WOULD APPRIECIATE YOUR INSIGHT, THANK YOU FOR READING THIS

    A:

    Please read our article â€CAN I TAKE MEDICATION WITH MY HERBS†located on our site under "Articles."

  • Click here to view in a new window

    Q: My co-worker has a 1 year old grand-daughter, who they recentlly found has 3 kidneys. This was discovered because she has constant fevers, and was not able to hold down any foods. The hospital she is currently taking the child to, has not assisted with any part of the child getting better. They seem to be giving her the run around. For example, scheduling appointments then cancelling etc. My co-workers seems to think, they are not getting fare treatment. Due to the fact her grand-daughter is receiving medicaid (government assisted health care). She says that they keep prescribing tylenol for the fever, and now the little girl may have a bladder infection. She has been, giving the 1 year old daily doses of tylenol for a few months now. I think that this should be stopped. Your knowledge is greatly appreciated.

    A:

    By all means, that child needs to perform the Children's Detox to undo all the harm the poor child has suffered.

    Product Links:
    Children Detox

  • Click here to view in a new window

    Q: My friend is pregnant with her first child and she is due in six weeks. She has an extreme case of high blood pressure and signs of high protein. What would you suggest she take to help lower her blood pressure?

    A:

    Oh wow! Have her take Eklampein Formula and Cardio-Vascular Formula . Sounds like she has Eclampsia. Please read our article on â€Eclampsia†under articles on our site.

  • Click here to view in a new window

    Q: Will you please share with me your regimen for asthma relief, that you discovered in 1996 (read your coffee article).

    A:

    I would suggest you first perform the Full Body Detox, followed by the Lungs and Respiratory Cleanse. Drink Lungs Tea while performing these kits, and use the exercises in the Mental Science Manual e-book to expedite your healing Beloved!

    Please read our article "Respiratory Problems" in our articles section.
    Respiratory Health

    Product Links:
    Full Body Detox
    Respiratory Cleanse and Regimen
    The Mental Science Manual